2023 DNFs

So, in 2023, I started doing a thing. After more than ten years of reading every book I pick up from cover to cover, I finally came to my senses and started listening to the little voice inside my head that says life is too short to be forcing myself to finish books that I’m not enjoying. And it was hard at first, going against my OCD. This was a busy year for me though, and with so much more on my plate, I had much less patience for books that just weren’t grabbing me, so something had to give.
But now that I’ve finally experienced the liberating sensation of being a DNFer, I definitely plan on doing it more! To be clear, just because I DNF a book doesn’t mean it’s bad. It means that, for whatever reason, I just wasn’t feeling it and saw no compelling reason to continue. For each of the books this year, that determination was made at around 25-33%, enough to safely say I gave it a fair shot. That said, I wanted to make this post anyway, in order to provide some of my commentary. Even though I may have given up on these books, others might find value in them. Perhaps my perspectives can assist you in determining whether these books are for you or not.
I’m also curious, what do others do with DNF’ed books? Do you try to review them or just set them aside and consign them to the void? If it’s a review book, do you notify the publisher? This is brand new territory for me, and I would love to hear people’s thoughts!
I received review copies from the publisher. This does not affect the contents of my reviews and all opinions are my own.
Thief Liar Lady by D.L. Soria
Mogsy’s Rating: DNF
Genre:  Fantasy
Series:  Stand Alone
Publisher:  Del Rey (July 11, 2023)
Length:  416 pages
Author Information:  Website
This story sounded like a fun take on the classic Cinderella story, but man, was it slow! For a novel whose tagline is “‘Happily Ever After’ is a total scam,” I expected a much more entertaining build-up, but instead, the characters were lackluster and the worldbuilding was non-existent. The Cinderella in this novel isn’t quite who she claims she is, and while I’m sure there’s more to her persona and plenty of secrets up her sleeve, I just didn’t care enough to stick around to find out.
Assistant to the Villain by Hannah Nicole Maehrer
Mogsy’s Rating: DNF
Genre: Fantasy, Romance
Series:  Book 1 of Assistant to the Villain
Publisher:  Red Tower Books (August 29, 2023)
Length:  342 pages
Author Information:  Website
This one may be a classic example of “It’s me, not the book.” I knew going into it that it would be romance heavy, being from Entangled Publishing’s newly launched New Adult SFF romance imprint. But from the quirky title, I thought I would be getting a fun-filled cozy romance fantasy, and to its credit, I think that’s what it tried to be? Rather than a cute romcom-type story though, what I found instead was forced humor that failed to elicit even a chuckle, as well as awkward banter between the two romantic leads. Didn’t sense much chemistry between them either, to be honest, but it seems I am in a very small minority who did not care for this book. If you are into this genre, Assistant to the Villain  may be more your speed.
There Should Have Been Eight by Nalini Singh
Mogsy’s Rating: DNF
Genre:  Mystery, Thriller
Series:  Stand Alone
Publisher: Berkley (November 21, 2023)
Length:  408 pages
Author Information:  Website
I’m disappointed that my first book by Nalini Singh turned out to be a total bust. I’ve wanted so long to read her books, but maybe this wasn’t the best place to start. While I’ve mostly seen her name attached to paranormal romance, mystery/thrillers are more my thing, so I thought I would give this one a try. However, it took way too long for anything remotely interesting to happen, and especially with this genre, I do expect my attention to be grabbed almost right away. It’s too bad, because I thought the setting of a remote mansion in New Zealand’s Southern Alps to be very unique, but unfortunately the story and characters were just too dull.