Before I begin my review, I would strongly urge you to not read the original blurb for this mystery and it’s even risky just looking at the cover. Why you ask? It’s spoilers. Spoilers on a grand scale that I have not seen before. For some bizarre reason the publishers seem to think that by telling you what the twist is from the outset that you will be desperate to find out what happens next… If this twist unfurled itself within a few pages of the book, then fair enough. But it doesn’t. It finally makes an appearance 60%-70% of the way into the narrative. So, to spare you this annoyance I have written the synopsis below and I have blocked out the spoiler on the cover.
That said this is not Graeme writing at his best, in my opinion. To date I have read one other nonseries title by him, The Undetective (1962) and then all the reprinted Theodore Terhune mystery series. It is the Terhune books which I loved the most, with A Case for Solomon (1943) and Seven Clues in Search of a Crime (1941) being my favourites.
Synopsis
Detective Sergeant Oliver Marsh has been in hospital due to developing life threatening septicaemia from a flesh wound. At the start of the book, he is finally allowed home to use his sick leave. But he decides to visit work beforehand. Here he learns that a putrefying body has been discovered in the attic of a farmhouse. The station is short-handed, and Oliver is keen to make a name for himself and get a promotion, so takes on the case. Things, however, are far from simple, as the case takes its toil on his weakened body and mind and causes further havoc in his fractured marriage. But if he discovers the truth, it will all be worth it – won’t it?
Overall Thoughts
Graeme presents us with an interesting puzzle of a case. The farmhouse is not only occupied but the inhabitants say that someone is always home bar the occasional 15 or 20 minutes. The hiding place for the corpse is an odd one too, as the corpse is not concealed in the attic, it is just dumped in. Surely, any killer would know that the smell or an errand would bring someone to the attic sooner or later?
Cover has been edited so a blue shape covers the spoiler part of the image. It is easy enough to find the complete cover online via Google Images.
The crime fiction trope of the lead detective having a dysfunctional or broken marriage or relationship, is usually associated with more modern mysteries, but this 1940s novel by Graeme shows it has earlier roots. From my own reading of the book, I don’t think the narrative tries to make you side with Oliver or his wife. Other characters in the story might have chosen a side, but I don’t think there is a pressure on the reader to do so. To me it just seems like they are ill-suited, temperament wise, and the demands of Oliver’s policework exacerbates this.
Despite the decomposition of the corpse, it is quickly identified, and Oliver gathers an impressive amount of information concerning the victim and those who knew him, in a matter of days. There is some growing tension as it appears that an inspector might be soon available to take over the case and the credit for solving it, something Oliver wants to avoid at all costs.
Unfortunately, what starts out as an interesting read, becomes increasingly boring and unsatisfactory. The plot shifts into a storyline which you might find in a depressing black and white B movie. The twist, which had been spoiled for me by the blurb, finally makes its appearance and to be honest I found the subsequent narrative the worse for it. It is unusual when a twist actually makes a story worse not better. With the way the narrative had been going previously, I thought we had the seeds of a Jean Potts novel in the making; an author who at her best provided stories with knife edge suspense. But alas this was not to be.
So, all in all not a good read. If you want to try anything by Graeme, I recommend starting with his Theodore Terhune series. Interestingly, one of the cases which features in that series, is referenced by Oliver.
Rating : 3.5/5

