I was in the need of an easy and quick read, so I picked this one up from my TBR pile, as my husband read it last year and thought it was quite good – he even promised me it had clues! (At the time of him reading this book, I was encountering quite a few mysteries which seemed to forget to put any in, so it was reassuring to know clues came included with A Third Class Murder !)
Synopsis
‘England, 1930. An antiques dealer is found robbed and murdered in a third class train compartment on a remote Suffolk branch line. The police believe they know who the killer is, and an arrest is soon made. A passenger on the same train, the Reverend Lucian Shaw, country parson and former army chaplain, is concerned that the police have the wrong man, and begins an investigation of his own. Before long, Shaw is drawn into a web of intrigue, deceit and murder which lurks beneath the surface of a seemingly peaceful country parish.’
Overall Thoughts
I found the opening scene of this mystery to be something of a mixed bag. On the one hand, I felt it was rather stereotypical in its depiction of a vicar and his wife in how they spoke and thought, but on the other hand I thought the future victim was effectively introduced. I could see that the scene was trying to provide a contrast between the sunshine and how everything was going well for the vicar, with the disharmony in Charlie and Freda Cokeley’s marriage and their antiques business. Their discord is not presented as the problems being one sided. Charlie is unkind and stubborn, but Freda is lazy and is obsessed with listening to the wireless all day, refusing to help in the shop. Nevertheless, the opening setup came across as a bit generic.
This novel arguably leans into some of the ideas W. H. Auden discussed in his essay, ‘The Guilty Vicarage’ (1948). For example, Auden opined that in the detective story ‘the corpse must shock not only because it is a corpse but also because; even for a corpse, it is shockingly out of place, as when a dog makes a mess on a drawing room carpet.’ I felt this was echoed in Morrison’s narrative just after the first corpse is discovered in the train carriage: ‘Both Shaw and Goggins had encountered death at close quarters before, but that had been abroad and in the febrile atmosphere of war; a violet death in the peace of the English countryside seemed somehow more shocking.’
Returning to the opening chapters, I don’t feel like I overly warmed to the central character, the Reverend Lucian Shaw. It’s not that I disliked him, but I was more neutral. That said he does grow on you a bit as the story unfolds. I was wondering whether the beginning of the book needed some humour to capture the reader’s attention more. The narrative gets more interesting as further characters are introduced and potential motives and murderers are revealed. With amateur sleuths in this type of social milieu and setup, I think it is almost expected that the sleuth in question is comfortable with people and adept at drawing information out of them. So, it was surprising to find that the Reverend Shaw might not be so good:
‘[…] he always felt a little more comfortable with the administrative work of the parish than with attempting to remember the names and faces of his flock. Events, meetings, services, these were predictable and satisfying, but people were sometimes … difficult […]’
Another aspect which is unusual about this story (and it’s not a bad thing), is that the 1930s setting shows the effects of the ‘Slump’ or Great Depression, with various working class and lower middle-class characters struggling with precarious finances. This is not something historic cozy mysteries often depict, so it was interesting to see its involvement in the plot here.
The initial stabbing of Charlie Cokeley is presented in an interesting way as the only person in the compartment was a woman who has now disappeared. It is not an impossible crime, and it doesn’t purport to be either, as a man is seen leaving the train prior to the train arriving at its destination, when train had to stop for a red light. However, this information adds more questions not fewer to the list. The murder weapon incriminates someone the vicar knows, but not much rescuing is needed, as their personal risk of being wrongfully arrested is short-lived.
From time to time the dialogue gets a little bit conventional/formulaic, such as when two policemen are arriving at the crime scene:
“Sorry sir,” said the Scotsman breathlessly as the two men exited the car, “but a murder! That’s not something you get every day round these parts. I can’t remember the last time we had one.”
“We don’t know it’s murder,” admonished Ludd. “All we know is a man’s been found dead […] Keep an open mind […] First rule of detection. Things aren’t always what they seem.”
Detective Inspector Ludd is a self-important and rude policeman, who is a stickler for procedure. I would say he is similar to Inspector Sullivan, Inspector Valentine and Inspector Mallory from the Father Brown TV series. If you like the show, then this book is likely to be your cup of tea. Ludd combines the reasonable intelligence and reluctance to work with amateurs which we see in Sullivan and Valentine with the rudeness of Mallory.
The writer doesn’t go over the top with how much sleuthing the vicar undertakes. The sleuthing he does fits into his role as a vicar and when he purposefully goes to question someone it is usually a more minor character, who the police have not properly talked to. The narrative doesn’t stay with the vicar for the whole story, as we get to see some of the police investigation as well, which means the vicar is not unnaturally forced into situations in order for us to be privy to what the police doing.
I was able to solve the case before the ending and I suspect many readers will be able to do the same, but I don’t think complete understanding of the solution occurs too early. The clues accumulate nicely and there is a good bit of character misdirection at one point. The ending fell a little flat for me as it returned to more generic waters and the police and vicar arrive at the same conclusion but in different ways. It was a good read, and I would try another one, but it has not left me wanting to rush out and get another book in the series straight away.
Rating : 4/5

