Compiling a Multi-Author Collection

I am glad to welcome guest author Judy Penz Sheluk today, who is talking about anthologies. Take it away, Judy! — Barb Goffman Compiling a Multi-Author Collection


by Judy Penz Sheluk  


Mega thanks to Barb Goffman, who was kind enough to
relinquish her regular spot here so that I could celebrate the Release
Day of  Larceny & Last Chances: 22 Stories of Mystery & Suspense .   As
Barb will tell you, putting together an anthology is a lot more
complicated than randomly arranging a few stories together, though there
is a bit of that. And while I can’t speak for Barb or other anthology
editors, I thought you might enjoy a behind-the-scenes look at how this
editor compiles a multi-author collection. Ready?   


Step 1: Send out the Call for Submissions. I always allow 90
days. This time around, I also capped entries at 80 in the hope that
authors would be less inclined to wait until the eleventh hour of the
90th day to submit.   


Step 2: Using a spreadsheet, I log every submission as it’s
received with the author’s name, pen name, email address, story title,
word count, and state/province/country. I ask for state/province/country
merely out of curiosity. In the case of  Larceny & Last Chances ,
there were submissions representing 29 states and provinces in the U.S.
and Canada. At this point, I also notify the author that their
submission has been received.  


Step 3: I read the stories in batches of two or three,
usually in the same week they are received. On my spreadsheet, I’ll
include a brief comment to remind me what the story is about. I also
keep a column of No or Long List—these are the “maybes” — I can’t really
make a final selection until all the stories are received and read.  


Step 4: Authors on the No list are notified by email, with a
short note explaining why their story is not a fit, e.g., didn’t
adequately fit the theme of larceny AND last chances (that, by the way,
is the #1 reason a story is rejected). I do this at the time the
decision is made so the author can find another home for their story.
Authors on the Long List are also notified by email, just letting them
know they’re still in the running. In addition to being an editor, I’m
also an author. I know what waiting for word feels like.  


Step 5: After all submissions have been read, it’s time to
reread the Maybes and start culling down the list. For  Larceny &
Last Chances , there were 38 on the long list. At this stage, I sent the
stories to Andrea Adair-Tippins, a librarian at the Whitby Public
Library, for a much-appreciated second opinion. Compare notes.  


Step 6: Send out final rejections or acceptances. Prepare
contracts and get them signed. Spread the word. At the same time, I’m
working with Hunter Martin, the graphic artist I commission for all my
cover art.   


Step 7: Sort the story order. Back to the spreadsheet, alternating by narrator (male/female/young/old) and story length.  


Step 8: Format the book for digital and print (I use Vellum,
which I love). Send out ARCs for blurbs/advance reviews (arranged well
in advance).  


Step 9: Get the book up on pre-order and schedule promotional opportunities (like this post).  


Step 10: Celebrate Release Day. Whew! Who knew 230 days could fly by so quickly?      


About  Larceny & Last Chances: 22 Stories of Mystery & Suspense  


Sometimes it’s about doing the right thing. Sometimes it’s
about getting even. Sometimes it’s about taking what you think you
deserve. And sometimes, it’s your last, best, chance. Edited by Judy Penz
Sheluk and featuring stories by Christina Boufis, John Bukowski, Brenda
Chapman, Susan Daly, Wil A. Emerson, Tracy Falenwolfe, Kate Fellowes,
Molly Wills Fraser, Gina X. Grant, Karen Grose, Wendy Harrison, Julie
Hastrup, Larry M. Keeton, Charlie Kondek, Edward Lodi, Bethany Maines,
Gregory Meece, Cate Moyle, Judy Penz Sheluk, KM Rockwood, Kevin R.
Tipple, and Robert Weibezahl.   Find it at:  www.books2read.com/larceny  


About the editor: Judy Penz Sheluk is a former journalist and
magazine editor and the bestselling author of two mystery series,
several short stories, and two books on publishing. She is also the
publisher and editor of four Superior Shores Anthologies. Judy is a
member of Sisters in Crime, International Thriller Writers, the Short
Mystery Fiction Society, and Crime Writers of Canada, where she served
as Chair. Find out more at www.judypenzsheluk.com .